Martindale-Hubbell 2024 - Badge
National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers - Badge
U.S. District Court / District of Massachusetts - Badge
Harvard Law School - Badge
Best Law Firms / U.S. News - Badge
Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly - Badge
Super Lawyers - Badge

Mass. Tribal Bribery Witness Doesn’t Spell Out Quid Pro Quo

Martin G. Weinberg, Attorney At Law Team

Law360 (April 27, 2022, 5:27 PM EDT) — A key witness in the Mashpee Wampanoag bribery and extortion trial stopped short of testifying Wednesday that the more than $50,000 paid by an architect to the tribe’s chairman were necessary to protect a multimillion-dollar casino contract.

Joseph Beretta, former president of architecture firm Robinson Green Beretta, told the Boston federal jury that he signed off on his associate David DeQuattro’s decision to cut checks to Mashpee Wampanoag Chairman Cedric Cromwell’s reelection campaign and later reimbursed DeQuattro for the payments.

But the testimony fell short of prosecutors’ promise to the jury during opening arguments last week that Beretta would say that — while he never asked DeQuattro — he knew the payments were being made to protect the casino contract.

Cromwell and DeQuattro, who were indicted in November 2020, have argued the lack of evidence of a quid pro quo is a “fatal hole” in the case. U.S. District Judge Douglas P. Woodlock allowed Assistant U.S. Attorney Christine Wichers to ask Beretta questions about his conversations with DeQuattro and what actions he took. But the prosecutor was not permitted to elicit testimony about Beretta’s state of mind or what he thought the payments were for.

The judge later sustained objections to Wichers’ questions to Beretta about whether anyone had previously asked him to write out a political contribution check to a business entity or whether he thought such arrangements were normal.

“The focus is on interactions by words between Mr. DeQuattro and Mr. Beretta,” Judge Woodlock said.

Beretta told the jury that after running the first donation by the firm’s outside counsel, they recommended he not make the payments.

“I went to David and said that they don’t recommend doing it,” Beretta said. “I said, ‘I’m not doing it.’ I said, ‘If you do this, make sure it’s correct because you don’t need a headache and the chairman doesn’t need a headache.'”

Hammering home the point, DeQuattro’s counsel Martin G. Weinberg prompted Beretta to agree that he never heard Cromwell and DeQuattro discuss the donations and that he never told DeQuattro to “go back to Cromwell and demand that he give a specific benefit to RGB for these donations.”

“You said you would not have signed off on donations if it was in any way connected with keeping RGB’s contract or business?” Weinberg said.

“Correct,” Beretta replied.

Beretta told the jury that he also made thousands of dollars in political donations annually to Rhode Island state and local officials to keep his “name out there” and develop business opportunities for the firm.

The government told the court they expected to call their last witness on Thursday.

The government is represented by Jared C. Dolan and Christine J. Wichers of the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the District of Massachusetts.

Cromwell is represented by Timothy R. Flaherty.

DeQuattro is represented by Martin G. Weinberg and Maksim Nemtsev of Martin G. Weinberg Law PC.

The case is U.S. v. Cromwell et al., case number 1:20-cr-10271, in the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts.

–Editing by Orlando Lorenzo.

Read the full article here.

Highly Revered & Recommended

Marty is a lawyer’s lawyer – an unparalleled legal technician with a philosopher’s vision. Marty sees the nuances in the shadows in the edges of the furthest reaches of the law and brings it all back to first principles and fundamental values.

NACDL Past President Martín Sabelli

Some lawyers have been gifted with extraordinary intellects, others prodigious trial skills, and still others a relentless work ethic. Marty has the rare combination of all three, and that is what truly sets him apart within the defense bar.

Robert M. Goldstein

Marty is the go-to lawyer for those with complex legal and trial issues – there is no one better. Most importantly, he is an all-around terrific person.

NACDL Past President Gerald Lefcourt

Whether it was his surgical cross-examination of co-defendant-turned cooperating-witness Joseph Lally or his home run closing argument, the Boston lawyer established that the evidence against Vitale simply was not there.

David Frank, Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly

God forbid I ever have a problem, he’d be my lawyer.

David Chesnoff

Contact Us

Fill out the contact form or call us at 617-227-3700 to schedule your free consultation.

  • Phone Icon Free Consultation
  • Gavel Icon High-Level Litigator
  • Experience Icon Decades of Experience

Free Consultation 617-227-3700